Entries Tagged as ''

Another opinion on IFQs

At the suggestion of Glen Brooks, the President of the GFA, who is currently very actively campaigning for IFQs in the Gulf of Mexico grouper fishery, I visited the web site of an association that calls themselves “Food & Water Watch” this evening.

Apparently Mr. Brooks didn’t look too far into the site before suggesting people visit it because I found this opinion of his group’s main focus…

Our oceans and marine resources in the EEZ are public property –– meant to be shared by and used to equally benefit all U.S. citizens. Unfortunately, recent trends have been toward management that gives exclusive access to parts of our oceans or certain resources in them to private entities for economic profits.

For example, many of our popular seafood choices, like red snapper, are depleted and have too many people trying to catch too few fish. Our federal fish managers have developed a new system to control how many red snapper get caught each year and which people do the catching. But the system they put in place tends to reward those that can catch more fish quickly (like large companies rather than small scale and perhaps more sustainable community-based fishing), because the right to fish is often granted based on how much fish an individual (or company) caught in recent years.

That seems like a well thought out and reasonable opinion to me.  Might go a long way toward pushing me off the fence I’ve been on regarding the issue.

After much debate and deliberation…

After much debate and deliberation the NMFS has decided upon a new motto.

As they are a government agency, they felt they should have a motto to define their objectives, which might not always be abundantly clear.  A grant was sought after and the intrepid researchers managed to corral some 2.3 million USD to finance the studies.  Words were considered, words were chosen and then it was all sent to a committee meeting in Las Vegas that took place over a five day weekend in late June.  There the words were reviewed, talked about, considered some more and then sent to the peer review subcommittee for further review.  While the main committee spent some time and grant money in the main casino, the subcommittee met in the sub-casino and discussed and considered some more.  After two more days of intense work on the part of these dedicated scientific types, the motto was scheduled for tentative agreement at a date to be determined as soon as the casino closed or as soon as the five day weekend came to an end, whichever occurred first.  In order to prevent any more over fishing from occurring the weekend was declared over a mere four and a half days after it began and all respective committee members retired to their quarters to hotly debate and discuss the issue over ten hours of intense sleep.

An entry is scheduled to be inserted in the Federal Register by an as yet un-named Federal Bureau of Something or Other and the public comment period will be publicly announced at that time in a relatively public manner.  Honest.

We here at the Settee Club have scoured the records of the peer review and have determined that the new motto for the NMFS is a quote from the great scientist Albert Einstein, a great and wonderful paragon of fishery science if ever there was one.  It is as follows:

“If the facts don’t fit the theory, change the facts.” — Albert Einstein