Death by Regulation

Bob Jones, of SFA, recently sent these interesting observations and figures to SOFA’s Bob Spaeth. He’s given us permission to reprint the email here, we think it bears some thought.

Greetings,

I was thinking about all the draconian cuts in fishing throughout the United States, so I thought I would look at what regulators have already done to the seafood industry in the southeast. These are the numbers that leapt out at me from my part of the world. We had a robust seafood industry in the southeast before the Magnuson Act was enacted and re-interpreted. As I’m writing this note, the South Atlantic Fishery Management Council is preparing to deal a death blow to the snapper/grouper industry as ordered by NMFS based on their interpretation of a selected portion of Congressional action. All numbers are taken directly from two NMFS publications: FISHERIES OF THE UNITED STATES, 1984 (page 4) and FISHERIES OF THE UNITED STATES 2006 (page 6).

The government numbers indicate what regulations have done to a once proud food producing segment of the US economy. If I have copied these numbers down correctly, it appears our industry has almost been managed out of existence for no good purpose. Why do the Councils keep taking the fish?

Bob Jones

Comparison of Commercial Fishery Landings by State (in million pounds)
  State   1984   2006
Florida 206,679 96,255
Alabama 26,405 34,052
Mississippi 476,997 221,838
Louisiana 1,931,027 844,027
Texas 104,082 116,860
Georgia 15,884 7,747
South Carolina 15,104 11,112
North Carolina 276,219 68,641

Comments are closed.